[quote]orion wrote:
…
Contrary to popular belief far less than 10% of all insurgents come from outside the Iraq and less than 10% of their attacks are aimed at Iraqi civilians.
http://www.csmonitor.com/2005/0923/dailyUpdate.html
Tactics of the Iraqi insurgency - Wikipedia [/quote]
An interesting choice of stats.
From the wikipedia article:
In February 2007, the Pentagon�??s quarterly report, Stability and Security in Iraq, found that “Although most attacks continue to be directed against coalition forces, Iraqi civilians suffer the vast majority of the casualties”.[3] In late 2006, the BBC News website covered the issue, noting that although “about 80% of insurgent attacks are targeted against coalition forces, the Iraqi population suffers about 80% of all casualties, according to US officials in late 2005.” This page, which includes an illustrative bar graph, was last updated November 2006.
Also from the wikipedia article:
A 2005 Human Rights Watch report analyzes the insurgency in Iraq and highlights “the groups that are most responsible for the abuse, namely al-Qaeda in Iraq, Ansar al-Sunna and the Islamic Army in Iraq, which have all targeted civilians for abductions and executions. The first two groups have repeatedly boasted about massive car bombs and suicide bombs in mosques, markets, bus stations and other civilian areas. Such acts are war crimes and in some cases may constitute crimes against humanity, which are defined as serious crimes committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack against a civilian population.”[6]
Glen Greenwald is interesting, but his rant is at least a year and a half old -and a lot of his “rebuttal” cites to even older information, from back in 2004.
Here’s some other info on foreign fighters in Iraq, including some analysis of captured al Qaida documents from late last year:
http://www.ctc.usma.edu/harmony/pdf/CTCForeignFighter.19.Dec07.pdf
There are obviously native Iraqi insurgents fighting as well - but al Qaida ( Al-Qaeda in Iraq - Wikipedia ) is the most ruthless and carries out the most devastating attacks - particularly those targeting Iraqi civilians. Most of the others seem to be Sunni. Some other main groups are the Islamic State of Iraq ( Islamic State of Iraq - Wikipedia ), the Mujahideen Army ( Mujahideen Army (Iraq) - Wikipedia ), the Islamic Army in Iraq ( Islamic Army in Iraq - Wikipedia ), Ansar al Sunnah ( Jamaat Ansar al-Sunna - Wikipedia ) and others. There are Shia as well - notably the Mahdi Army ( Peace Companies - Wikipedia ), and probably some Iranians. Hell, there are even some Marxists ( Iraqi Armed Revolutionary Resistance - Wikipedia ).
However, if al Quaida kills the most civilians and if al Quaida is largely foreign - both of which are true - there should be some hope of working with the remainder - particularly if they are tied to people who have political power in the Iraqi government. Of course, there’s the possibility too that the remainder groups will devolve into civil war too - the hope is that the national Iraqi military can be trained well enough to be ready to deal with them.