[quote]DoubleDuce wrote:
[quote]batman730 wrote:
[quote]Ripsaw3689 wrote:
[quote]theBeth wrote:
[quote]DoubleDuce wrote:
In all seriousness, insulin sensitive cancers would grow much faster with this kind of diet. And if the guy was putting on a lot of fat tissue, it could definitely have increased his risk. People don’t seem to understand that much of what we do effects our cancer risk, it isn’t something that just happens or doesn’t happen.
I do find it funny that they call it a high fat/high protein diet, when the carbs are through the roof.[/quote]
All cancers are insulin sensitive - they have 10-20 times the amount of insulin receptors as normal cells. So yeah, you can literally feed cancer on that kind of diet, not to mention it would cause fatty liver disease which increases cancer risk considerably. [/quote]
I’ve heard a bit about keto diets being very beneficial for cancer patients, but most of the reasoning have sounded very bro-sciencey. Has there been any legitimate studies done to see the effect diet has?
[/quote]
Dr Thomas Seyfried has gotten some attention about this lately claiming that “keto diets beat chemo for almost all cancers”. He claims that chemo and radiation therapies show no significant increase in long term survivability but keto diets do. He claims that big pharma is suppressing this for economic reasons.
He cites a few mouse studies that are interesting, but way too thin to support the kind of claims that he is making. He also cites some human “trials” that would be difficult for any reasonable person to see as clinically significant. One sampled exactly 2 patients. Another sampled 56.
There really isn’t any significant amount of randomized human clinical data from which to draw conclusions.
There is more clinical data linking higher incidents of cancer (and liver cancer specifically) to diets containing over 10% animal protein. There are problems with many of those studies as well.
Same old story: X causes cancer. No wait, X actually cures cancer. No wait, this tribe from this remote location never gets cancer and they eat lots of Y, ergo Y must cure/prevent cancer. Deodorant and electromagnetic fields definitely cause cancer etc, etc, etc…[/quote]
But it is known that insulin makes cancer grow. It only seems logical that keeping insulin low would minimize cancer growth.[/quote]
Sure it does. However, “seems logical” is not the same as “supported by legitimate clinical evidence”, which was Ripsaw’s question.
There is also, like I said, a fair amount of evidence linking high percentage animal protein diets with cancer markers, so it also seems logical that a low protein diet is the way to go.
The only thing that consistently seems to reduce the incidence of illness and prolong life afaik is systematic under eating and periodic fasting. If that’s true, I expect most of us are SOL regardless.