[quote]Limbic wrote:
Toddy, I Spy:
Just to give you a sense of what you’re asking me to accept. This is just numbers gleaned from what’s posted on irongame:
Gene Rychlak June 7, 2003 810 lb
(?) 2004 1005 lb
Are you really asking me to accept that Rychlak gained 195 lbs. of strength in 6 months? There’s your sport. Did his deadlift progress at all in that time?
Read below, Toddy, there’s great instruction here.
[/quote]
No, read my post again. I’m not asking to accept that he gained “195 lbs. of strength in 6 months”. I’m asking you to accept that he gained 195 lbs on his bench press in a Powerlifting competition.
He gained 195 lbs of skill. He may have found a shirt that works better for him. He may have altered the shirt he had. He may have gotten a better arch. Put his feet in closer. Moved them out wider. Got faster. I don’t know what he did in those six months. He probably did get stronger, though, along with whatever else helped break 1000 lbs.
Maybe he had 1000 lbs in him 6 months ago, but he wasn’t confident enought to try it. Maybe he just wasn’t having a good meet six months ago and decided to stay relatively low on his lifts. Again, I don’t know.
So, back to what you asked, whether or not he gained 195 lbs of strength. If you don’t believe it, then don’t. I don’t believe it was all strength either. But I do believe he gained something that made him better at the sport of bench pressing.
Look, take football placekickers, for example. Kicking is a skill. It requires strength, but it requires a lot more, too. Jason Elam made a 63 yard field goal in 1998. This was his sixth NFL season. His longest the year before was 53. His longest ever, besides the 63, was 56.
So what happened? Did he, in one football season, gain enough strength to add seven to ten yards to his kicking length? No. He got better in other ways. Just like Gene, I’m sure he did gain some strength, but there’s so much more to it. He may have a better kicking stroke. Maybe he found the best way to kick to maximize height and distance.
You know kickers use different shoes, too. Not just different from other kickers, but different than eachother. Most wear some type of socccer shoe. Some kick barefoot. Elam wears a Nike Tempo soccer shoe. You know what else? He wears his kicking shoe a couple sizes too small, so it will fit real tight. Whoa, sounds kinda like someone fitting into their bench shirt that fits too tight.
Let’s continue with the kicker comparison. So Jason hits a 63 yarder. In some eyes that makes him a better kicker. He knows he has the confidence and the ability to hit from that far. So did his kickoff yardage go up as well? Was he making more special teams tackles? Maybe maybe not. So when you ask if Gene’s deadlift went up, too, it’s irrelevant. Whether it did or not doesn’t add to or take away from what either of these men accomplished. They both had record setting accomplishments regardless of what else they did that day.
I don’t think you’re seeing the big picture. Powerlifting is a sport. It has competitions, rules, legal and illegal equipment, referees, etc. When someone competes in a powerlifting meet, they are testing themselves in much more than strength. You still need to be strong, and powerlifters are strong, but it taked more than raw strength.
On to some other things you have said:
“My opinion is that this website is intended to help people develop true strength, not hide behind their squat suit. Something that takes 15-20 minutes to get into, and it’s not a prop.”
This website has a section of its forums called “Strenght Sports”. That would include powerlifting. So I guess this website does help people use their “prop[s]”.
“As I said before there is no context where that statement can stand other than a JackAss-type taunt, but I doubt JackAss is even that strong raw.”
JackAss benches over 500 raw.
Look, I get it. You don’t like gear. That’s fine. Don’t use it. Don’t compete in powerlifting meets that allow it. Hell, I doubt you have any aspirations to compete at all. But, since you have never competed, and have never tried any gear, you really shouldn’t attempt to criticize that for which you do not understand.
Elam probably had the wind help his kick, so the kick doesn’t count,
Toddy