Waylander - The natural peanut butter should be right next to the 'nasty peanut spread'. Smuckers' natural is pretty good. Beware the organic smuckers if you're on a budget, it's like 2 bucks more because it's organic. I buy 'Teddy' brand as well. I go through a couple jars a week, easy. I think both are like $2.50 a jar (+/-).
The real nut butters (almond, cashew, walnut, etc) are excellent, but usually quite expensive. If you have a food processor, you can easily make your own. You'd easily make up the money you spend on a processor and making almond or cashew butter versus buying them.
Little tip-- take a knife and mix the oil into the natural PB then put the PB in the fridge and it won't separate back from the oil.