You're kidding me right?
I have found customized dog tags (most of the time) to be a copy cat of something else and very unoriginal.
And what kind of 'ball player' are you? I am guessing a basketball player by your cockyness.
I have some dog tags, but two were gifts, and the other two sets are my ROTC tags and one for my youth group. I don't wear any of them except when I need to.
My advice spend the 20-30 bucks you're going to spend on it and buy something like another month of gym membership.