Well doing all those for 5x5 IMO on the same day would leave you not giving the second and even worse third movement the attention it deserves.
But I hear you. Volume Frequency. I actually think both could and can be used with great success. One you will beat the hell out of a body part and do Major damage. then give it a full week to heal before doing it again.
The Other you dont tear down the tissue as much in one go so you dont need as much healing time before doing it again. Though if going this route I wouldnt go with the smae rep scheme daily I would cahnge it up a bit. 3-4 reps one day 6-8 another, 12-15 on the third. Better yet put the high rep between the to heavier load sessions and have a two day break between the 3-4, and 6-8.
Short answer I dont think either is better for everyone. They can both work and by rotating them and others you can find out what works best for you and keep it fresh and interesting.