[quote]Dr.PowerClean wrote:
Good post, Tirib, but here’s another question. I have been puzzled by my constant soreness because I did not experience it this way in my heyday, my eight year “career” as a shot/disc thrower during which time I got progressively stronger and bigger.
But was that more a function of age (early 20’s), or training style (narrowly focused training on heavy benches, inclines, squats, and power cleans). Now I am blessed with all sorts of creative ways to “shock” the muscles, HIIT, EDT, crossfit, etc., and they do indeed shock them. Soreness and growth, soreness and growth.
Is it simply that younger, highly conditioned elite athletes training for a specific performance goal are less likely to experience substantial DOMS soreness? Or is it possibly that high amounts of "gear" decrease or eliminate this degree of soreness? Or are there anatomical/genetic variables here as well, or other reasons I can't think of?
Doc[/quote]
I really hate not knowing the answer to stuff like this, but the truth is I don’t. I trained in my 20’s and was sore all the time. I’m 43 now and I’m still sore all the time, actually I’m probably not quite as sore most of the time now than I was then. I don’t get debilitatingly (is that a word?), can’t move type sore, but it’s readily apparent.
No doubt changing rep ranges, frequency, volume etc. around will cause more soreness than if you do the same thing all the time. I would also think that sports specific performance based training would be less apt to bring on soreness, especially in younger well conditioned athletes than physique based training. Actually training for size is probably the most DOMS inducing type of all because there are no rules beyond whatever works for that person so all parameters are up for grabs all the time. Even strength training most of the time probably doesn’t cause it as much for most people.
I will also say that while poor nutrition and rest will make it worse than it has to be, good nutrition and rest won’t prevent it in those for whom it happens regularly.
As to why some soundly progressing folks get sorer than others and some hardly or not at all in the wake of similar work? I have no idea. I just know that for me it matters. Even when dealing with imbalances, the sorer side is bigger 100% of the time. I’ve never used gear, but from what I’ve read it’s the same. Some do some don’t.
This is a prime example of why I always bristle at universally, superlatively phrased advice. It just ain’t ever as simple as “this is what it is”. People argue day in and day out around here about what the “best” whatever is as if there were such a damn thing.