I think I get where you were going with this comment, but it sounds kinda... off. Just to clarify for the OP, Surge Workout Fuel doesn't tear your muscles down automatically by itself. Like others have commented, it can help you keep the intensity high later into your training session by delaying some symptoms of general fatigue.
If you have to choose only one of the two, and lifting is your primary method of training, I'd say start with the Surge Recovery. Experiment with the "classic" plan of having a serving right after training, but in some sessions, try having a serving a little while before (or during) your training to see if you notice a difference.