[quote]StrengthDawg wrote:
[quote]chris_ottawa wrote:
[quote]StrengthDawg wrote:
FWIW, I would quit considering pin squats or chains wtc. Your form needs tweaking. You are not weak at the top, so pin & chain work will only compound your issue. Peform the full squat with lighter weights till your form is perfect. Build the muscle via accessory movements. You PC is weak which is why your doing that “twitch” / stall or hatever you want to call it. Like I said before, work on your hip hinge / strength. Quit worrying about percentages and other irrelevant and distracting stuff. It’s all mental masturbation.
[/quote]
No disrespect, but I don’t completely agree with what you are saying. It’s true that working with lighter weights could help with technical errors in some cases, but for anyone except a complete beginner you would have to do very high volume and stay far from failure (like Sheiko programs). From personal experience, I would say that perfecting your technique with lighter weights doesn’t carryover to maximal lifts. My squats used to fall apart around 90%+, but they looked good with lighter weights. What helped me was two things: daily max squatting and special exercises like I mentioned above. In the case of Sheiko and similar programs, they work because you do so many repetitions of the same movement that your body learns to do it more efficiently. You still have to check your technique because if you are doing high volume with bad form then you will only make things worse, it only works if you can maintain proper form.
About pin squats, if you do them the way I was saying (reaching depth) then they will help the bottom end, not the top. I agree that chains won’t help, but I think bands might be useful because the force you to keep your balance. One way or another, the competition lift needs to be the basis of your training and not variations, they can help but they don’t replace it.
I realize that this is a bit of a controversial topic because everyone seems to have their own ideas of how to fix technical errors so I will start another thread where we can argue about that.[/quote]
So your advice to the OP is that you don’t agree with what I’m tossing out there?
May I ask how long you have been seriously lifting? By what you wrote, I’m going to guess that you are new to this game. Few who have been lifting for years do daily max effort squats. It’s nonsense.
You are also recommending that one do Max effort Anderson squats off of pins? So a guy is supposed to take a 1m for a ride only from the bottom up? Looks like spine injury time to me. How many times did you do any of this personally and what was the results? Your writing “I think” this does that makes me believe you have little practical experience of this stuff you are spewing. Honestly dude, you sound like a guy who been lifting for 6 months. I may be totally wrong, whatever. I just think your comments are unfounded and not grounded in sound lifting priciples.
Anyways, Haldor man. Good luck with your squat. I hope you fix your issue and get back to kicking ass. [/quote]
You mean the way you did to my comments? I don’t usually get involved in internet arguments anymore but if you’re going to go around telling people their opinion is wrong, than don’t get all pissed when other people do the same to you. There are more than one way to do things, and rather than having people explain why they suggested it; you just say they are flat out wrong. Shit like this is why it takes new ideas so long to come out. The second something different is suggested, it’s shot down under the premise “How long have you been lifting”. Maybe you should let the OP decide what he does and does not want to try, and learn what actually helps him correct his problems.
For instance when I said chain squats, it wasn’t to address an upper back weakness, it was picked to help him both develop the correct positional strength as well as the ability to apply explode out of the hole in the correct position without falling forward. I know because I have done them. I did everything I suggested and you know what, It worked for me and that is why I was comfortable enough to recommend them.
More over, you have no idea what the OP’s learning curve to technique fixes are and what exercises will end up helping him the most.That’s why guys swear by different “money” exercises that they usually admit they overlooked.