[quote]Moriarty wrote:
The Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development estimates that 1.1 million people who were born in Canada were residing in other OECD countries at the beginning of the 21st century. Of these Canadian-born emigrants, the lion�??s share (82%) resided in the United States. As of the year 2000, over half of the Canadian-born residents of the US (58%) had been living there for over 20 years; another 30% had been there for over 10 years. Many were so well settled that they evidently had no intention of returning to Canada: by 2000, 46% of Canadian-born emigrants had become naturalized American citizens, according to the 2000 US Census.
Between 2000 and 2004, an average of about 68,900 Canadians departed for the United States every year; in contrast, an annual average of about 6,100 US residents immigrated (obtained permanent resident status) to Canada during the same period.
Think about that for a minute. Even though the United States has 10 TIMES the population of Canada, Canadians still come to the United States at 10 TIMES the rate that Americans go to Canada. You would think that if Canada had equal quality of life as the United States (or even if the United States had only marginally better quality of life than Canada) that the number of people leaving the United States for Canada would dwarf the inflow of Canadians based on sheer numbers.
Canadians have to be, by far, the dumbest people on the planet. That is the only way of explaining the fact that they practically trip over themselves to leave the modern Eden known as Canada headed for the wasteland that is the United States.[/quote]
How about we do this:
9 - number of US cities with a population of over 1,000,000
2 - number of Canadian cities with a population over 1,000,000
All things being equal, anyone wanting to move to a large city has a 9/11 = 81.8% chance of moving to the US and a 2/11 = 18.2% chance of moving to Canada. Anyone wanting to move to a city with a population over 3,000,000 has a 0% chance of moving to Canada, and a 100% chance of moving to the US.
now, you mentioned the migration rate from Canada to the US, and the US to Canada rate. Within the US, what is the migration rate into New York and LA, and the migration rate out of NY and LA? How does this compare to the US-Canada rate?
Of course, this isn’t taking climate or geography into consideration.