Give The Orphanage a try. I didn’t realize it was subtitled when I rented it, but it still managed to spook me a bit. That’s probably the only recent scary movie I’ve seen that wasn’t gory.
My vote for scariest of all time is The Exorcist (the extended version).
I also thought Teeth was scary, but for a totally different reason.
I have not seen the extended version of The Exorcist! I forgot about that! Thanks I will Netflix it along with The Teeth.
I did like Ravenous, for anyone who is looking for a different kind of movie.
I should warn you though, there is some gore in Teeth. Not much though. It’s nothing like the gore in the Saw movies. I’d also have to say that this movie is much scarier for men. It’s a bit of a satire as well.
Is Ravenous the movie with Guy Pearce? I heard that was good, so I’ll have to add it to my queue.