I’ve been in law enforcement, done some bouncing, and I’m about to become an attorney. I’ll add my observations then throw out a question for the guys on the board.
First of all it’s been my overall experience that for the most part trained martial artists, boxers, or even “real” weightlifters are generally not going to be your biggest problem, as they have less to prove.
My bouncing was at a teen club, so my experiences are probably minor league compared to some of these folks. while the crowd was a pretty rough element it was easier because they were smaller and less likely to be intoxicated (although we caught a few trying to sneek drugs or alcohol). I’d say that what these guys are saying is dead-on. When I go to a drinking establishment and see a smaller bouncer I just assume he’s some kind of martial arts stud. Also, consider if the place supplements bouncers with off-duty police? This may not only deter problems with other patrons but with law enforcement but I’ll get to that.
Anyway, almost without fail the times when I’ve had to put hands on some little darling it was because they were either fighting with each other or with another bouncer. I remember once having to wrestle with a pretty good size kid who was sweaty, slippery, extremely agitated and he was fighting with a co-worker. I had to put him in a ju-jitsu lock and lead him out. I later learned that my co-worker not only had a bad habit of grabbing the kids first instead of talking and in this case had used a racial slur toward the kid. Again the quality of your crew is huge.
To contrast the above experience another co-worker seemed to always be at the right place at the right time, not only did he remember the kids personally but was very adedpt at spotting group pattern movements, agitated kids, and he really had an eye for what clothing meant what. As the guys above have said, your crew is huge. In addition, alertness, people skills, and a few good holds or locks will serve you well.
One thing you may want to consider is the potential liability. We live in a highly litigious society and you’re going to have to lay hands on some folks. Furthermore you may have to account to local law enforcement went things go down. At the club where I worked there was an afterhours incident in the parking lot and the kids weren’t even customers just trouble makers. Anyway the local PD had always been particularly worthless when it came to helping us, even on what should have been very good arrests on drugs, weapons, warrants, etc, but they actually investigated this incident because some gang-banger got thumped by a weightlifting bouncer. Anyway you may want to ponder the liability issue.
My question to the board is have any of you ever been sued civilly or had any trouble with the police, or know of anyone who did in the course of your job?
If you’re wondering I’m 5’11 and was 220-230 when I worked there, done a stand up style of jujitsu off n on for years. I’m kinda serious looking but I have a fairly laid back demeanor, and my Spanish is so-so. I’m past 30 and I’d just as soon talk as fight, it’s better in the long run.