First, everyone is going to be different. Second, it probably depends largely on what you are used to as well as things like your insulin sensitivity and general health. Protein by itself is actually fairly effective at replenishing glycogen. It will probably also have varying effects on nervous system activation. I’m personally not a fan of pre-workout calories of any kind for that reason.
Bottom line is, no one can tell you what will work for you. Try whatever you want and see how your workouts are, and how your strength and body composition respond (you’ll have to give it some decent time). If it works, keep doing it, if it doesn’t then stop.