[quote]orion wrote:
[quote]Apollo1029 wrote:
This is not a bash fat people thread
I am sitting in my nutrition class today and my nutrition teacher calls obesity a disease and says scientists have found an obesity gene. At first I didn’t really pay attention but on my way home from class and I started to dwell on it and it just didn’t sit right with me.
To me calling it a disease is saying that a persons actions play no part in it. It takes personal responsibility away and justifies it to a person. I would agree that it is a lifestyle or an addiction but not a disease. Also, this gene my teacher was talking about was a gene that regulates leptin in the hypothalmus. Leptin does play a part in weight mamagement but how do you call a gene that regulates a certain hormone or body function an obesity gene? I feel that environmental factors play way more of a role than genes in obesity.
Am I way off base here? I can take critisism if I am wrong. It is important to me because I plan on going in to the medical field and I would like to hear others point of view.[/quote]
You could google the hunger winter in the Netherlands and the subsequent rise of diabetes in people who were hit by starvation mode while they were at just the right time of their mothers pregnancy with.
Meaning, it is not just genes, but genes, environment and the inheritance of “learned” traits i.e. epigenetics and never shall those be untangled.
You could say, well, but, behavior to which I would reply, yeah well, genes, the environment and whatnot forms behavior too.
Finally, if some tells you that they have found A or THE gene for something or other, put your brain into ignore mode so that their sloppy thinking may not soil the purity of your well ordered intellectual universe.
Unless of course your mind looks like the average garage, then just put in on a shelf somewhere.[/quote]
They just recently had a segment on a CBC radio one program “Quirks and Quarks” about epigenetics.
This is a link to the pod cast.
http://www.cbc.ca/video/news/audioplayer.html?clipid=2161607978
it’s about 10mins long.
It’s about the biological fingerprint of poverty(obesity is mentioned).