The "ickiness factor"?!
A guy with a healthy, athletic physique seems to have the opposite effect on me. There's tremendous commitment, and patience involved with athleticism and a healthy lifestyle.
Those things translate into life and relationship skills. I find a neglegent-looking man significantly less (if at all) attractive. If he can't commit to eating right and being active, then how would he ever inspire me to go on being that way?
Having said this, I suspect that most of the women surveyed were not necessarily representative of athetic, confident women who value good health and strong character above all.
(In themselves and others)
Don't worry guys - I think you'll all be fine. You might just have to settle for hot, active, intelligent women who aren't threatened by strong men.