T Nation

New Meaning to Doggy Style!


#1

Did anyone hear about this???

Back in August, a now-17-year-old Scarborough girl -- her name protected by the Youth Criminal Justice Act -- was sentenced by Justice Paul Robertson to 20 months probation after pleading guilty to the Criminal Code offence of "compelling bestiality" -- as in using a neighbour's pit bull as a sexual weapon in the anal rape of a then-12-year-old boy.

There were conditions on the girl's probation order, of course, including counselling to address "sexual offending and anger management."

The Crown prosecutor, Kim Motyl, had sought a custody and community supervision order of 18 to 20 months, all to be followed by a year probation and counselling.

The facts of the case are as follows:

In August 2003, the then-15-year-old girl was hired by a neighbour in her apartment building to look after her pit bull terrier while she went away to the west coast, and left her explicit instructions not to bring any other person into the apartment.

The police report is three pages long. And it is graphic.

It has the girl attending the apartment to feed the pit bull, and taking along the 12-year-old "victim" who also lived in the same building. They were sitting on the couch when the dog climbed up and began "humping" the boy.

Both, according to the report, thought it was "funny."

"We need to get rid of his horniness," the girl reportedly said, and then instructed the boy to get down on the floor on his hands and knees where she then forcibly pulled down his pants and underwear, and put the pit bull in position.

The boy told her to stop -- that it was "no longer funny."

But it wasn't about to stop.

"The victim began crying in pain," reads the police report. "After about 10-15 seconds of the dog penetrating the victim, the accused began hitting the dog on the head to break him off. The accused instructed the victim not to tell."

Back at his own apartment, the boy initially told his mother that his "puffy" face -- swollen from crying -- was the result of banging his head on a shelf. After he went to the bathroom and discovered he was bleeding, however, he let the entire story spill out, including showing her the scratches on his back that were consistent with claw marks.

According to the police, the boy's mother confronted the girl, but did not immediately report it to the police because she feared the girl was not only a bully, but a member of a gang in that end of Scarborough.

It was only after a social worker at the boy's school called the mother to discuss her son's increasingly bad behaviour did the mother disclose the events of that summer. The social worker, in turn, called Children's Aid who, in turn, called the cops.

The girl was originally charged with three criminal counts, one for compelling bestiality, one for bestiality on a person under the age of 14, and another for sexual assault.

The last two charges were withdrawn when the girl pleaded guilty to the first count. During the sentencing, Judge Robertson said that, despite the Crown's prosecutor's use of the words such as "repugnant" and "perverted," he could find "no evidence before him that the physical injuries (to the boy) were anything more than transient in nature."

He also said he "would not equate this offence with one of incest or a serious sexual assault" that would result in "psychological damage far in excess of the physical nature."

"The offence before me was spontaneous, lasting about 10, 15 seconds," said the judge. "It started as an ill-advised joke between friends."

It was Tony Loparco, the head Crown in Scarborough, and prosecutor Kim Motyl's boss, who asked for the appeal.

"From a legal perspective, I knew the appeal would likely be turned down, simply because the girl will soon be 19," said Loparco. "That, and the fact that young-offender rulings are rarely changed.

"But, was it worth a try? Yes, it was," said Loparco. "Imagine what that boy went through, with a pit bull.

"Sometimes you just despair for humanity.

"It's frightening. It truly is frightening."


#2

Damn... how unfortunate...


#3

That's just...um...wow.


#4

Unfortunate indeed.....but what's his max bench?


#5

I'd like the judge to take it in the ass for 10-12 seconds from a pitbull and see how tramatic it was for him.


#6

I second that. That is some fucked up shit


#7

I second that


#8

There is something about that story that just strikes me as comical. Maybee if I find out what it is I'll get some therapy, but until then I'm just gonna laugh my ass off every time I think about it.


#9

The Judge needs to be braught befor a judicial inquest. How dare he make such statements the job of an officer of the court when children are victoms is to champion the plight of the victom.

10-12 secs isn't nearly long enough.

That Judge needs to be held accountable and be put infront of a judicial inquest have his tenure stripped and be disbarred.


#10

At some point you just gotta stop caring, or you'll go crazy. I mean this is horrible, but what are you gonna do? The world is a fucked up place.


#11

Unfortunate isn't how I would describe this incident. How about fucking criminal!, evil perhaps. Not unfortunate. Unfortunate is when I order an iced tea and the waiter brings me a diet coke. Ass raping a 12 tr old boy with a pit bull is evil, pure evil. It's times like this that make me wish there really was a fiery pit of hell that fucks like these two can burn forever in. Damn this shit pisses me off!!

This bitch, including that silly fuck of a judge should both get ass fucked by a god damn saint bernard for 10 or 15 seconds. After all, it's only transient in nature.

WTF!

That judge, IMHO, is just as evil as that bitch.


#12

you're not alone.

what happened is pretty fucked up, but im thinkin the kid was more messed up by the reactions of his mother than the butt rapage.


#13

There has got to be a special room in hell for this girl..and another one (filled with giant pit bulls juiced up on enough testosteone to float a battleship) for the judge.


#14

NO! You never stop caring. Never. The indifference of good men is among the greatest evils of all. Fight, fight until the very last fiber of your being is STRIPPED of all strength, until your bones sear with pain. Fight for good until you are no more, and only then shall the world become a better place.

Be the vengeful striking hammer of God. This is my purpose, and should be the purpose of all good men.


#15

You and I are on the same page. Evil will not be tolerated.


#16

So what the fuck are you doing about this particular injustice? Have you gotten her sentence increased yet? Have you prevented this sort of thing from happening again?

The way America is run has very little to do with the will of the people. Even if it were, your opinion would be drowned out by asshats like that judge.


#17

Yes, although the whole story is wrong in many ways, I see a comical aspect as well. If it had been a Yorkshire Terrier or a pet gerbil, I guess it actually would have been funny...


#18

But God isn't vengeful. He is all-loving.


#19

... to those who have enough sense to connect the dots and think and act in ways to redeem themselves, at least.


#20

Only time will tell whether this woman tries to redeem herself.

The Bible is very contradictory. I don't go by it. I use some lines from it, but that's just because they sound pretty hardcore, and get good reactions from people.

I certainly don't believe God is all loving.

You could say that my train of thought is best paralleled by The Boondock Saints. Watch that movie, and you'll understand basically how I deal with the world.