If it smells like brownies....yep!
Elusive is a cool guy. You should time your meetup with him when he's having a cheat day; had a thread that showed the 12,000 or so calories he'd stuff his face with in 24 hours. Insane.
Maybe you two could cook for him and watch him scarf it down. In some cultures, that's part of the courtship process.
By the way, I believe The Mighty Stu is also in NY (not sure if in Brooklyn) and I'm sure he trains at a good gym.