I have yet to meet a knowledgeable family doc or urologist regarding TRT. TRT clinics have been the best in my experience, but just too expensive.
I ended up with a family doc that will prescribe T, but I have to manage E2 on my own.
He probably said your TT was "superhuman" because 1200 is the top of the normal range for most labwork. Above 1200 is "supraphysiological" - just meaning it's more than the body can typically make.
I bet you DID feel great at that dose! You probably can't argue that you want to feel that great again, but you can argue if you have health issues at your current reduced dose (fatigue, ED, anxiety, insomnia, etc). What is your TT now? There's no way a urologist is going to prescribe ANY dose that puts you over 1200. My doc feels strongly that "men my age" day below 500.
What did he mean by "significant atrophy"?!?