I'm using it now. I have been using it for about 8-10 days. It is a little too soon to really get into overall effects, but I am documenting what I see so far.
I do know I filled out like I do when taking in heavy carbs...only without the heavy carbs. I think you can see some difference in the pictures.
I agree....people who were training and eating wrong before will confuse any results seen by outsiders.
To really see how it works, it would probably be best to pick someone who bulked up before and had pictures of it to compare to eating the same while taking this supplement after dieting down.
Granted, more muscle may be added, but body comp would be the greatest indicator.