[quote]The Mighty Stu wrote:
[quote]jehovasfitness wrote:
[quote]SSC wrote:
[quote]jehovasfitness wrote:
[quote]The Mighty Stu wrote:
No one maintains 5-6% body fat for more than a few days if at all.
S[/quote]
I am going to respectfully disagree here, and this is only based upon one person that I’ve tested. Now, he was not 180#s mind you.
IIRC, 5’9 165ish at the time.
I did a skinfold on him, 6 site, and everywhere I pinched it was like the back of someone’s knuckles.
His BF% was 2.x%, granted even I realize that’s not 100% accurate, so let’s say a 3-5% variance which is quite acceptable for skinfolds.
That was his normal walking around condition. He’s probably 15-20#s heavier these days and not as ripped, but still in very lean condition, sub 10%
[/quote]
There is a really, really big difference between even 8% bodyfat and 5% bodyfat, as far as performance, health, and visible looks are concerned. I have to agree with Stu on general principle on this one.
I think that the majority of people (and yes, I know your background,) underestimate how incredibly lean even 10% bodyfat is. But what I’m saying is that the guy you measured was 2-% measuring, which could have up to a 5% variation - which could make him closer to 7-8% (realistically,) and now he’s 15-20lbs heavier which will add additional digits of bodyfat - 10% or slightly more in all likelihood.
Again, Stu is saying no one is walking around like that all.the.time. The same seems to go for the guy you’re referring to.
Unless I’m missing something here, IDK.[/quote]
I dunno, here’s a current pic. Dude is a freak for sure.
[/quote]
No doubt. But the human body doesn’t want to be that lean (I mean honest to goodness 4-5% bodyfat, not just getting that numeric reading from a skinfold). Thibs has agreed in the past that most top contest ready bodybuilders aren’t truly that lean, more like 6-7%, but it sounds cool to say that you’re as lean as humanly possible without actually dying -lol.
I’ve known, and stood along side many amazing competitors who look like their skin has been peeled off, fibers running every which way along their erectors, inner lat attachments, you name it, and they’re truthful enough to guess their leanness at about 6% at the lowest. As impressive as your friend is (and he truly is sporting an impressive physique), I wouldn’t peg him any lower than that at best.
I know that actual numeric readings are essentially pointless, but as has already been echoed, most people can’t fully comprehend just how lean real single digit bodyfat is. Every idiot in the gym sporting a wife beater either is, or knows someone who is under 10% and huge.
Not arguing, or starting a fight here, just disagreeing based on my own knowledge and experience
S
[/quote]
It’s cool dude, Respect your opinion and you’re not the type to just argue to argue.
This current pic is him much heavier than we I did the skinfold years ago, I’d say about 8 yrs or so. Either way, you’re right skinfolds aren’t the most accurate, and if I had to guess, if he were to have used a Bod Pod way back when it would have been around 5-7% which still has a small bit of error, but not much.