[quote]Bigjitsu wrote:
Xen Nova wrote:
if you wrap your legs the other way on the scorpion leg lock, you’re doing a “lockdown”, which is the fundamental part of the 10th planet 1/2 guard methodology. best way i’ve seen to control your opponent if you pull 1/2.
just re-watched that move in the vid again and noticed the leg position is incorrect for most of all the 1/2 guard moves I know. You want your outside leg on the bottom and your your inside on top (like Xen mentioned).
The reasoning is that you can use you out side leg to “open” your opps leg and spread out his base and make it easier to sweep/create space. There is some debate on this but the way it was explained to me was that it saves you the trouble of trying to switch feet later.
However, this method of controling the leg leaves you open to your opp going what I call “cross body” (laying across your hips with his back to you)or being flattened via “crab walk”. But then there is no perfect solution, just the flow.
My current approach to half-guard, which is very popular at our school, and I have seen from a lot of the guys at Alliance, and Paragon (Jeff Glover in particular) is to shoot my inside arm inbetween my opps legs and hook his outside leg
(opposite the one I am controlling with my legs) and play from there.
This vid shows the entry with a transition in X-gaurd
Some good half-guard
- Another approach to danews question
part of half guard sweep series - YouTube
- Old school Mario Sperry
part of half guard sweep series - YouTube
[/quote]
Yeah, you could get the leg lock with either leg, and if you like using the inside leg on top, and you feel it offers you more options, no reason not to do it that way.
About the name (someone mentioned that it sounded too WWE like), it comes from Catch Wrestling (which the WWE has it’s roots in). A lot of the Catch moves have somewhat flashy names because Catch wrestlers often times traveled with circuses and the announcers felt that the flashier names would attract more patrons.
If you think the “Scorpion Leg Lock” is bad, then you’d hate one of the counters to the move (could be done with either of the opponent’s legs tying up your leg). It’s called the “Standing Indian Death Lock”. LOL. How’s that for a flashy name.
The thing that I don’t like about a lot of BJJ half guard sweeps that I see demonstrated, is that practically no BJJ guys that I see (even guys like Garcia, Jacare, and other extremely talented and skilled BJJ guys) control their opponent’s hips, or make their opponents carry their weight, while in half guard (or guard).
No disrespect to these guys meant at all btw, they are phenomenal grapplers. I just don’t think that BJJ teaches to do this.
That video you posted (the first one) is a good example of this. The guy on the bottom was able to even get his arms between the other guy’s legs because the guy on top was not controlling his hips, and in fact, his hips were well above his opponent’s center of gravity.
So yeah, if the guy on top isn’t controlling your hips, has space between your hips and his, isn’t making you carry his weight, and has his hips well above your center of gravity, then sweeps like those work great.
But, if the guy on top has his hips below yours, has no space between your hips and his, makes you carry his weight (basically is controlling your hips), then a lot of those sweeps don’t work so well.
Also, things obviously change between gi and no-gi. The techniques in the video with Sperry wouldn’t work nearly as well if you didn’t have the gi to grab hold of to manipulate your opponent. But obviously work quite will with the gi on.
In the end it comes down to what you can make work though, so to each his own.