Maybe... I have to say this is one of the best superhero games I have played in a very long time.
I have played this game for a while, and there is nothing that this game doesn't lack. Graphics, gameplay, and CGI cut scenes are phenomenal. The fights are not repetitive because your always upgrading combos. The enemies are not easy to kill (I started off playing it on "HARD"), you are always constantly countering attacks if you don't want to die fast. Yes, you die fast in this game because this ain't Superman. After a few shots, you're dead, so sometimes you have to hide and be stealth.
But overall this game is "dark" and I'm fucking loving it.
Anyone play this yet?
EDIT: Here is the Gamespot review that fuzzy was talkn about http://www.gamespot.com/xbox360/action/batmanarkhamasylum/index.html