T Nation

Autophagy: Is a Caloric Deficit a Precondition?

Hi Coach,

I’ve been unable to find anything conclusive written on whether or not autophagy is exhibited if weekly calories are kept at maintenance or above, and intuitively I would assume that as long as one fasts for 16+ hours the mechanism would present itself. I was hoping you could weigh in.

Also, certain writers seem to favour dry fasting to trigger this mechanism. Notably, your old acquaintance Joachim Bartoll. What are your observations here?

I believe that the main trigger for autophagy is AMPK and the main thing that halts/prevents it is mTOR (more systemic mTOR, not muscle mTOR).

When you are fasting for a significant period you will trigger AMPK (which is activated when you need to mobilize stored energy). If you fast for 16 hours and then eat above maintenance you will have an AMPK release during the fast and then you will have a large mTOR activation during the eating period.

Thus you can stimulate autophagy during the fasted period but it will be halted during the eating period. Even if you are to consume a supra-maintenance level of calories after your fast, it has no impact on that is happening during the fast. While you can have a surplus over the course of the 24h period, you are in a deficit during the fasting period and you need to mobilize stored energy which means that you will release AMPK and start autophagy.

Of course, the longer the fast, the more autophagy you will get.

As far as dry vs. hydrous fasting, I couldn’t say. I know that Jocke swears by dry fasting. But I’m not sure if you can actually measure the difference in autophagy between both, if any.

Thank you coach. My autumn looks as if it will be decidedly less active with regards to NEPA so I was thinking about experimenting further with fasting then but am considering toying with it now but then wanted to know that being in a surplus does not negate the effect.

Hearing a non-Scandinavian use the colloquial “Jocke” made my day!

I have an article that will run shortly about a system that Paul and I designed that include several type of days, including fasting days, with adapted training for each type of day

Primer 5/2 finally being published? Exciting!

I don’t know if you’ll be putting an article out, or if it’ll be published as a book as per,

But if what you are referring to is the system posted here Health Benefits of IF vs Cortisol Problems of Type 3's, i.e.,

then would

M: Fasting
T: LB Hyper + Rock climbing (max effort - intensity)
W: UB Strength
T: Athletic (Rock climbing)
F: Fasting
S: UB Hyper
S: LB Strength

Be a non-sucky way to do it?